South Korea Taking North Korean Nuclear Threat in Its Own Hands
by Russ Wellen
Would South Korea ever go the nuclearization route like North Korea?
On the heels of North Korea announcing that it had made nuclear warheads small enough to launch on a missile, South Korea has learned that one of those missiles, the Rodang, is capable of reaching South Korea. Whether or not that is correct, in the New York Times, Choe Sang-Hun reports:
&ellips; one senior United States military commander, Adm. William E. Gortney, said at a Senate hearing last month that it was a"prudent decision" to assume that the North"has the capability to miniaturize a nuclear weapon and put it on an ICBM."
At Foreign Policy, Jeffrey Lewis agrees:
Our studied skepticism of North Korea's capabilities is not in our long-term interest. We should be in the business of seeking moratoria in North Korea on nuclear and missile tests, not daring Pyongyang to do more.
How should we go about that? Lewis on how not to:
By setting the hopeless goal of denuclearization and insisting upon unstated preconditions the United States is mostly giving itself an excuse not to do anything.
At Huffington Post, Joe Cirincione states:
As odious as it may seem, it is time to re-engage with the regime."While there are currently no good or viable options to rolling back the North's nuclear program," writes my colleague Philip Yun,"a multilateral diplomatic approach that addressed some of its strategic interests has a chance of at least freezing activity."
In the National Interest, Eric Terzuolo advises applying the new U.S. policy toward Cuba toward North Korea, as well.
In Havana, the president admitted the failure of long-standing U.S. policy, an uncharacteristic move for a U.S. political leader:"What the United States was doing was not working. We have to have the courage to acknowledge that truth." … Why shouldn't we"own" our failure vis-à-vis North Korea in the same way?… In Havana &ellips; President Obama emphasized the need to put the past behind us, and to find common ground between erstwhile adversaries. … Perhaps what was lacking in our approach to North Korea was respect and reassurance. &ellips; As with Cuba, we should be able to find something positive to accentuate in our discussions with Pyongyang.
In other words,"perhaps we just need to 'contextualize' North Korea's hostile gestures correctly, and try to view things from their perspective." Terzuolo dreams of"a reconciliation 'trifecta'" that reaching out to North Korea, along with the nuclear deal with Iran and the opening with Cuba, would constitute for the Obama administration,
In the interim, as John Feffer writes in his latest piece at Foreign Policy in Focus, Should South Korea Get the Bomb?, polls show that the majority of South Koreans, as well as some of the conservative media, are in favor of their country developing a nuclear-weapons program. It would probably, in view of its technological prowess and presumed preliminary research, be a piece of cake. That is, if South Korea were willing to expose itself to much of the same international enmity as North Korea. Developing nuclear weapons would make South Korea a rogue nuclear state, like the other few states that have developed nuclear weapons in the years since the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty was ratified in 1968.
Feffer notes, however:
For others in South Korea, the nuclear option is just to scare China into putting more pressure on North Korea."I don't think that South Korea actually wants nuclear weapons," said Park Syung-je of the Asia Strategy Institute in Seoul told The Washington Post."It's a way of saying to the Chinese that 'if you don't cooperate on North Korea, then we're going to get nuclear weapons of our own.'"
The possibility that the Islamic State could get its hands on nuclear material continues to increase the more time goes by. Similarly, the West has allowed the North Korean nuclear situation to fester. If the West, led by the United States, can't summon up the diplomacy needed to defuse both situations, one or the other will blow up in our faces.
- Be Wary of a China Witch Hunt
- Is North Korea Really that Crazy?
- Kim Jong-un's Dialogue Offer
- North Korea: The Cost of War Calculated
- Asia's Other Nuclear Standoff
- Preservation of the Asian Territorial Order
- Indonesia: East Asia's Rising Star
- China's Economic Multilateral Diplomacy
- China: When the Dragon Wakes
- Empowering China's New Miracle Workers
- The Influence of China in Bringing Peace to Myanmar
- Nationalism, Japan, and a Changing Asia
- More Prominence for India
- Modi Is Really Popular in India
- Australia Establish a Modern Slavery Act?
- China's Creditor Imperialism
- China: Xi Jinping Unbound
- Tri-Border Maritime Cooperation Foundering
- Money Talks in China’s Cloistered Internet
- North Korea Ready to Talk, But Who's Listening?
- What Can We Expect From Indonesia's New Defense Chief?
- Asia's Cities Against North Korea
- The Trumping of Asia
- China's State Security Strategy
- Australia's Agenda for Integrating the South Pacific
- Australia's Turn to Lead on Climate Change?
- Understanding the North Korea Threat
- North Korea: A Cold Northern Spring
- The Fastest-Growing Humanitarian Crisis
- Trump's Looming Hard Line on China
- Trump's Visit to the Philippines
- Trump's Mouth: Greatest Threat to Both Koreas
- Why Kim Won't Give Up His Nukes
- China's Communist Party By The Numbers
- The Grim Scale Of The Rohingya Crisis
- Rohingya: Ethnic Cleansing Leads to Refugee Crisis
- North Korea's Devastating Artillery
- North Korea Facts and Figures
- North Korean Defections
- Australians Urged To Eat Kangaroo Meat
- Can The U.S. Intercept A North Korean Missile?
- Troop Levels on the Korean Peninsula
- Japan: Shinzo Abe Wins in Landslide
- Ghost Collateral Haunts Loans in China
- North Korea's Cyber Warfare Cell that Worries the West
- Girls Freed From Mumbai's Brothels Learn Hindi To Retrace Trafficking Routes
- Yoga Tycoon Rises with Modi
- India Honors Nepali Woman Who Freed 12,000 Girls From Sexual Slavery
- India: Affordable Housing Plan Won't Fix Homelessness
- Indian Farmers Discover Flower Power
- India: Child Brides On The Rise
- Tsukiji Fish Market: Fighting To Save Tokyo's Culinary Heritage
- Pakistan: Sindh Province Cracks Down On Child Labor
- Nepal Fails To Deliver Relief To Quake Survivors
- Afghanistan: Refugees and Repatriation
- Australia Shark Attacks Could Take Bite Out of Tourism
- Australia Disappointed by Japan's Continued Whale Hunts
- Thousands March Demanding Change To Australia Day
- Australian Wine Exports To China Soar
- Philippines Narcotics Agency Takes Over Drugs War
- Philippine Troops Kill 15 Islamic State Supporters
- Philippines Asks China for Help in Fight Against Islamic Militants
- South Korean Perceptions of North Korea
- North Korea's Nuclear Infrastructure
- Countries in Range of North Korean Missiles
- Who Can We Trust To Measure Poverty?
- Instability, Quagmire, & Peace
- China's Vast Digital Potential
Article: Courtesy Foreign Policy in Focus.
"South Korea Taking North Korean Nuclear Threat in Its Own Hands"