What a pleasant surprise! Mexico, whose government routinely supports human rights violators throughout the region, played a key role in thwarting an effort by a group of countries to weaken the region's most important human rights commission.
Mexico - alongside Chile, Colombia, Costa Rica, Panama, Canada and the United States - succeeded in defeating a proposal by Venezuela, Ecuador, Bolivia and Nicaragua to strip the 34-country
The semi-independent body, known as the
It's by far the best - if not the only - thing the OAS has to show. Over the past decades, the commission and its
Venezuela and its allies, whose presidents already control all government branches and want to clamp down on the last vestige of criticism in their countries - the media - had mounted a diplomatic offensive over the past two years to effectively silence the two OAS agencies.
Fortunately, the Venezuelan-led group - in this case, with Ecuador acting as its spokesman - failed in its effort.
The group was left totally isolated at the end of a 12-hour special session of OAS foreign ministers that ended at midnight Friday in Washington.
"It was a resounding victory for the commission, and a major defeat for the Venezuela-Ecuador bloc," said Jose Miguel Vivanco, head of the Americas section of the
Vivanco added that only at the last minute, when Ecuador and Bolivia threatened to withdraw from the commission, the bloc was given a face-saving way out. Argentina helped the group introduce a vague line in the final document that keeps the issue alive by authorizing future OAS meetings to take it up, he said.
To my surprise, Mexico's 3-month-old government of President Enrique Pena Nieto - of the
At the OAS meeting, Mexico's Foreign Minister Jose Antonio Meade gave his unconditional support to the commission and the raporteur's office.
Because of its size and diplomatic weight, Mexico's position was key to help counterbalance Brazil's efforts to reach a consensus that would accommodate the Venezuelan-bloc's demands.
After Meade's speech, I called former Mexican Foreign Minister Jorge Castaneda, who supported human rights causes during his 2000-2003 stint, and asked him whether Pena Nieto is changing the PRI's traditional foreign policy for the better.
"Not at all," Castaneda told me. "This OAS vote was an exception to the rule, in part because Mexico's ambassador to the OAS is very good, and because both the commission's president and its technical secretary are Mexicans."
According to Castaneda, Pena Nieto has pretty much returned to the PRI's tradition of embracing dictators.
Castaneda noted that when Cuba's dissident blogger Yoani Sanchez visited Mexico recently, she was not received by any government official. When Pena Nieto visited Venezuela for late President Hugo Chavez's funeral, he did not meet with any opposition politician. And when Latin American countries elected Cuba's military dictator Gen. Raul Castro as president of the region's CELAC group of countries, Pena Nieto enthusiastically supported the move, he added.
My opinion: It's true that Mexico's new PRI government may not have abandoned its historic support for anti-U.S. authoritarian governments.
That may be ingrained in Mexico's ruling party's DNA, as I corroborated when I asked Pena Nieto in an interview shortly after his election about his foreign policy priorities, and his first reaction was to mention almost everything except the promotion of democracy and human rights in the region.
But let's give Mexico credit for having done the right thing this time. In part thanks to Mexico, Venezuela and Ecuador's demagogic leaders were left isolated and defeated - at least for now - in their efforts to silence all critical voices in their own countries, and the most important institutions that defend human rights and press freedom in the region.
- Latin America's Fastest-Growing Economies
- A Post-Castro Era Looms for Cuba
- It's Time to Delist Cuba
- Evolving United States - Mexico Relations
- Mexico's Drug War: Balkanization Leads to Regional Challenges
- Venezuela's Maduro Off to a Bad Start
- Venezuelan Opposition Leader Gains New Political Clout
- Venezuela's Maduro Hurts his Own Case
- Venezuela Lags Behind in Social Gains
- Argentine President May Be Hurt by 'Francismania'
- A Guatemalan Tyrant Faces Justice at Last
- The Free Market Experiment in Latin America
- Surprise! Mexico Backs Human Rights Cause!
- The Deal That America and Russia Must Make Following Chavez's Death
- Venezuela Election: David vs Goliath Contest
- Venezuelan Elections: Rehabilitated Neoliberalism vs 21st Century Socialism
- Chavez: American Nemesis, Latin American Hero
- Open Letter to The Economist - RE: 'Hugo Chavez's Rotten Legacy'
- Argentine Pope Could Impact Politics in Latin America
- Argentina Shoots Itself in the Foot Over Falkland/Malvinas Islands
- Brazil Should Stop Being Self-Absorbed Giant
- Mexico's Education Reform May Prove Historic
- Everybody is Upbeat on Mexico — Except Mexicans
- NAFTA at 20: The New Spin
- Venezuela Vice President Maduro Will Raise Anti-American Rhetoric - For Now
- Chavez's Populism will Remain Popular for Decades
- Ecuador, The Dictatorship of the 21st Century?
- With Chavez Absent, Venezuela is in Limbo
- United States - Europe Deal Will Impact Latin America
- Latin America's Corruption Starts at Top
- Argentina-Iran Deal Makes a Mockery of Justice
- Haiti's Man-Made Hell
- Salvadoran Gang Leaders Achieve a Measure of Redemption
- Latin America Should Not Be an Asterisk
- Militarizing Latin America: Four More Years
- Latin America's New Leader: Raul Castro
- The Falklands Referendum: A Hemispheric Balancing Act
- Argentina's Leader Populist, But No Longer Popular
- Mexico's Cartels and the Economics of Cocaine
- Super-Rich Pay Lower Taxes in Latin America
(c) 2013 Tribune Media Services, Inc.