French movie star Gerard Depardieu made the wrong choice by seeking Belgian and Russian citizenship to avoid paying higher taxes in France. He should have moved to Mexico.
Recent studies by
Depardieu has said that he is renouncing his French citizenship over French President Francois Holland's plan to raise taxes on incomes above
Last week, Russian President Vladimir Putin officially granted him Russian citizenship, after the internationally known French actor had set up residence in Belgium to obtain Belgian citizenship.
But Depardieu would pay much less in most Latin American countries. According to Andres Solimano, a Chilean economist and co-author of a recent study by the
Comparatively, in the United States, following the
"Clearly, the super-rich in Latin America pay much less taxes relative to their income than the super-rich in Europe or the United States," Solimano told me. "That's especially the case in Mexico, and in Central American countries."
The 2012 ECLAC study by Solimano and Juan Pablo Jimenez, which is entitled Economic elites, inequality and taxes, notes that the world's richest person - Mexican telecommunications magnate Carlos Slim - and many other Latin American billionaires benefit from distorted tax systems.
Tax evasion is rampant in the region, and most taxes are collected from "indirect" taxes on alcohol, tobacco and other goods that are consumed by the general population, the study says.
A separate OECD study says that personal income taxes amount to 1.5 percent of Latin America's overall gross domestic product, as opposed to an average of 9 percent in industrialized countries such as the United States, Germany and Japan.
In Latin America, most taxes are collected from corporations that pass on the cost of tax hikes to consumers and from indirect taxes on consumer goods, rather than from individuals as in the world's richest nations, the study says.
Asked whether Latin American countries should raise taxes on the super-rich, Solimano told me that "simply raising taxes on the super-rich won't solve the problem of inequality in Latin America."
The reason is that in today's globalized world the super-rich will simply pack and leave for another country, as
In addition, most countries in the region would need to better regulate compensation of CEOs, he said.
My opinion: There is no one-size-fits-all solution to Latin America's tax distortions, in part because tax agencies in some countries, such as Argentina and Venezuela, have become political mafias that spend much of their energies persecuting government critics, or business people who they don't see as sufficiently loyal.
I'm not sure giving these tax agencies more power would do any good.
Some of the region's low-tax countries would be better off raising taxes on the super-rich, while others would benefit from doing the opposite, and - much like Putin did in Russia - rolling out a welcome mat for tax-strangled foreign millionaires. What's best for Mexico may not be best for Panama.
But most countries in the region badly need to fix their dysfunctional tax systems. Perhaps the big headlines about Depardieu's country-hunting will help put the issue on the agenda. Merci, Gerard!
- Salvadoran Gang Leaders Achieve a Measure of Redemption
- Latin America Should Not Be an Asterisk
- Militarizing Latin America: Four More Years
- Obama May Help Latin America -- without trying
- Latin America's New Leader: Raul Castro
- The Falklands Referendum: A Hemispheric Balancing Act
- Argentina's Leader Populist, But No Longer Popular
- Cuba's Role in Venezuela May Grow -- For Now
- Mexico's Drug War: Persisting Violence and a New President
- Mexico's Cartels and the Economics of Cocaine
- Super-Rich Pay Lower Taxes in Latin America
- Accused Guatemalan War Criminal Hasn't Run Far
- Venezuela Political Crisis Deepens with Delay in Chavez Inauguration
- U.S. Congress Could Learn from Mexico's National Accord
- Some Latin American Countries Among World's Least Corrupt
- U.S. May Pay More Attention to Latin America in Obama's Second Term
- Mexico's Pena Nieto has Luck on his Side
- Enrique Pena Nieto and Mexico's Drug War Opening
- Chavez Names VP Mudro as Heir as Cancer Relapses
- Obama Should Send Thank-You Note to Chavez
- Constraints Facing the Next Mexican President
- Obama's Latin America Policy May Change -- Slightly
- Latin America Needs More Engineers
- Latin America's Growing Media Conspiracy
- Victory May Not Boost Chavez's Regional Clout
- College Rankings Should Alarm Latin America
- New Mexican Leader's Trip Signals Continuity
- Massive Fraud in Venezuela Election? Unlikely
- Colombia Peace Talks May Impact United States - Cuba Ties
- Brazil Could Break the Mold in Anti-graft Battle
- Mexico's Geopolitical Strategy
- Latin America Gets Bad Marks in Innovation
- Colombian President Juan Manuel Santos on Battling the Cocaine Trade
Copyright © 2012 Tribune Media Services