Russia is Withdrawing from Syria and the U.S. Should Follow Suit (Photo: Oxfam International)
By Phyllis Bennis
For too long Russia and the United States have tried to out-muscle each other by escalating the Syrian war. Now, for once, they've got a chance to escalate their efforts to end it.
In a surprise announcement, Russian president Vladimir Putin announced that the Russians were withdrawing “most of our military” from Syria beginning immediately.
According to the TASS news agency, Putin said he hoped the withdrawal “will become a good motivation for launching negotiations” and “instructed the foreign minister to intensify Russia's participation in organization of peace process in Syria.”
The withdrawal, along with Putin's restated support for a political settlement, could help move forward the fragile UN-brokered Geneva talks on ending the Syrian crisis that began on the same day -- as well as the tenuous UN-negotiated cessation of hostilities. “Those Russian servicemen who will stay in Syria will be engaged in monitoring the ceasefire regime,” TASS reported, indicating that the pilots and crews of the 50 Russian warplanes and helicopters that have been based in Syria would be withdrawn.
The withdrawal is an important step that should help reduce the level of violence in the deadly war. But questions remain.
Putin made clear that not all Russian forces would be withdrawn, and that Russia's airbase near Latakia, as well as Moscow's small but symbolically important naval base at Tartus on the Mediterranean coast, would remain open -- though they “will operate in a routine mode.” Putin said the two military bases should be “protected from the land, from the sea, and from air,” leaving open the question of whether Russian bombers “protecting” them might also continue bombing raids in Syria, flying from outside Syrian borders.
The Syrian conflict is simultaneously a civil war -- pitting a brutal government against a multitude of political and military opposition forces -- and a proxy war in which a host of outside powers are fighting for various regional and global hegemonies. And all of those overlapping wars are being fought to the last Syrian.
The reduction of Russian military attacks in Syria, along with Putin's renewed call for greater Russian engagement in the peace process, may set the stage to reduce, though certainly not end, the proxy war component of the overall conflict.
A real reduction of violence, a durable ceasefire, and a viable peace process leading to an end to the Syrian war will require much more -- more from Russia, certainly, but even more from the United States and its allies. There’s no indication yet that Russia's move was coordinated with Washington, although White House spokespeople indicated that a Putin-Obama talk might be possible.
In the meantime, Washington should follow Russia’s lead and pressure its own proxy forces to shift towards diplomacy. The withdrawal of U.S. troops, special forces, drones, and warplanes from Syria, paralleling the Russian move, would be an important first step. Further moves must include an end to both the CIA's and the Pentagon's programs to train and arm rebel forces in Syria. Finally, the U.S. should pressure its regional allies to stop arming Syrian opposition forces, which could also keep those U.S.-supplied arms out of the hands of ISIS and the al-Qaeda-linked Nusra Front.
All of those moves would, like the Russian withdrawal, reduce the proxy war raging in Syria -- and give Washington greater leverage to urge Russia and Iran to go even further and stop arming the Syrian regime.
For too long Moscow and Washington have tried to outmuscle each other by escalating the devastating Syrian war. Now, for once, they’ve got a chance to escalate their efforts to end it.
- Israeli - Palestinian Realities
- Backing Russia's Syria Ceasefire
- Trump's Israel Ambassador Pick Should Set Off Alarm Bells
- Iraq: A Huge Ethical Leap Backwards
- Deadly Stalemate in Yemen
- Iran: Crime against Humanity?
- Deadly Terror in Turkey
- Donald Trump, the Middle East, and American Foreign Policy
- Trump and the Iran Nuclear Deal
- Trump and Israel: Big-League Issues and Huge Repercussions
- Trump's Israel Ambassador Pick Should Set Off Alarm Bells
- Erdogan Warns Europe That Turkey Could Open Migrant Gates
- Europe Should Not Freeze Turkey's Negotiations to Join the EU
- Will the Battle for Mosul Change the Power of the Kurds in Iraq?
- Israeli Blockade of Gaza is Inherently Violent
- Are U.S. - Saudi Relations Finally Souring?
- An Outdated Relationship with Saudi Arabia
- The International Dimension of Aleppo
- Iraq's Traumatized Minorities: A Test Of Unity After Mosul Offensive
- Mosul, Iraq, ISIL and the Levant
- U.S. Should Stop Saudi Arabia's War in Yemen
- Israel and Saudi Arabia: Strange Bedfellows in the New Middle East
- Using Civil War to Build an Authoritarian Regime: Turkey's Policy towards Syria
- Assad Regime Must Pay Reparations to Help With Costs of Refugee Crisis
- No End in Sight for Israel's Rightward Drift
- Realizing Peace
- Saudi Arabia's Foreign Policy and the Failure of the Doha Oil Negotiations
- Saudi Crisis Deepens
- Why Exactly Does Saudi Arabia Fund the Spread of Wahhabism?
- ibn Abd al-Wahhab?
- Iraq's Future as a State
- The Post-Davutoglu Era in Turkish Foreign Policy
- From Paris to Istanbul, More 'War on Terror' Means More Terrorist Attacks
- Countries With the Most Troops
- The Old Oil Order Is Collapsing
- Islamic State: In Retreat or Transition?
- Challenging ISIS on its Own Turf
- Stabilizing Syria's Northern Border
- Politics of the Turkish Conflict: The Kurdish Issue
- One Last Chance for Peace in Yemen
- Syria after the Russian Intervention
- Jimmy Carter's Role in Securing Middle East Peace
- The Islamic State's Cash Flow Problems
- Syria's Moderate Opposition Lives
- Bombing ISIL Like Watering Its Roots
- Islamic Extremism Potentially Synergistic
- Russia is Withdrawing from Syria and the U.S. Should Follow Suit
- Islamic Extremism Is Nothing if Not Protean
- Hillary Clinton's State Department Armed Saudi Arabia to the Teeth
- The Islamic State's Obvious Next Step: Arming Its Drones
- Enabling Police Brutality in Egypt
- Why Are Disproportionate Numbers of Islamic Extremists Engineers?
- When Islam Polices Extremists
- It's Not Only the U.S. That Israel Resents
- U.S. Support for the Saudi Regime is a Humanitarian Disaster
- Can We Not End Wars Anymore?
- The Children's Crusade
- The Art of Dissidence and Diplomacy
- Saudi's Shiite Cleric Execution Going to Cost Them Big
- Independently Wealthy: ISIL's Sinews of War
- Causes & Consequences in Yemen
- Saudi Arabia: Real Progress or Window Dressing?
- Is Russia Actually Targeting Civilians in Syria?
- So Why Did Turkey Shoot Down That Russian Plane?
- Syria: For Money or Liberty?
- Russian Intervention in the Syrian Civil War
- A Greater Threat to Syria Than ISIL
- Israel: National Security and International Legitimacy
- Israel Should Stop Evicting Palestinians
- The Arab Uprisings Five Years After
- The Ghost of the Islamic State Future
- The Global Militarisation Index
- The Geopolitics of Religious Liberty
- Towards a Sectarian Political Order?
- Violence, Hostility and Religion Today
- Putin's Syrian Quagmire: Costs as well as Benefits for the US
- Religious Politics & Illiberal Religion
- The Geopolitics of Cheap Oil
- Islamic State: Timeline of 2015 Terror Attacks
- Insights Into the Kurdish Resistance Movement in Turkey
- The Schrodinger Solution for Syria
- U.S. and Saudi Arabia: A Toxic Alliance
- Turkey's President Gets Majority at Terrible Price
- A Radical Win-Win Solution for Syria
- Odds Stacked Against Mahmoud Abbas
- The Middle East's New Nakba
- A Kumbaya Moment for the Middle East? Hardly
- On Paper, Coalition Should Crush Islamic State
- What Happens When the Islamic State Has Its Own Air Force?
- Stop Cheering for Russia in Syria
- Inevitable Triumvirate: Syria, Russia & Iran
- Is Putin Really as Foolish as We Are?
- Is Russia the 'Main Engine' of the Destruction of ISIL?
- Turkey: Plague Upon the House of Erdogan
- Was Bin Laden Killing Result of Intelligence?
- Why Doesn't the Establishment Take World Peace Seriously?
- The Star Trek Fallacy
- In Foreign Policy, Nature May Love a Vacuum
- Prospects for a Nuclear-Weapon-Free Zone in the Middle East
- Stephen Walt's Call to Adopt a Containment Policy Toward the Islamic State
- Kids Paying the Price for Yemen's War
Article: Courtesy Foreign Policy in Focus.
"Russia is Withdrawing from Syria and the U.S. Should Follow Suit"