Parents: Stop Being So Awkward With Money
Kids want to learn more about finances from their parents, if only parents would open up
Parents tend to tiptoe around the topic of money as if it's a squeaky toy and their children are napping nearby, but their children would likely be better off if they made some noise. That's according to a new survey by T. Rowe Price , which found that parents are largely silent, sometimes deceptively so, when it comes to discussing personal finance. About 3 in 4 parents admitted to not being honest with their children about money, including in regard to their own financial lives.
Even if parents try to avoid the topic, says T. Rowe Price financial planner Stuart Ritter, children often pick up on their anxiety. "Kids are seeing what's going on anyway, and without your context around it, they're going to draw their own conclusions," he says. That's why he recommends opening the conversation by talking about financial goals and values.
"Set a financial goal that's important for your family," he says, such as paying for college. Then, when other expenses come up, such as a vacation or a new car, parents can explain the trade-offs. Perhaps the family is taking a quick weekend beach vacation instead of a weeklong trip to put more money into the college account, for example. Kids can learn a lot from hearing how parents make those financial decisions, says Ritter.
The survey, which for the first time also included interviews with 8- to 14-year-olds, suggests that kids are hungry for that kind of information. One in five young respondents said they want to know more about saving money, and almost the same proportion said they wanted to learn more about earning money. Meanwhile, only half of parents say they talk to their children about savings goals and spending and savings trade-offs. Far fewer teach their children about inflation and investing.
Many parents avoid talking about money because they don't want to share how much they make, or even worse, have their children know and then tell their friends. (One in three parents surveyed said they specifically avoid discussion of the family's financial state.) But Ritter says there's no need to talk numbers -- it's sharing values that's more important. "You're not breaking out the W2 forms, but talking about setting goals," he says.
For parents who are still squeamish about the topic, Ritter suggests starting with how money works. For example, some kids think a credit card provides an endless supply of cash. Parents can explain that they work to put money into their bank account and then use that money to pay bills, including the credit card, each month.
Previous research suggests that parents play a powerful role in shaping their children's future money habits, for better or for worse. Financial educator Mary Ann Campbell has found that money attitudes such as "live within your means" are passed on through generations. At the same time, people who saw their parents overspend and struggle with money often repeated the same mistakes themselves. Her findings led Campbell to conclude that parents should "model the behavior you want [your kids] to have."
Laura Vanderkam, author of All the Money in the World, suggests identifying your own money philosophy and the types of lessons you want to pass on. Vanderkam, a mother of three, says she first thought she wanted her children to learn frugality, just as she did growing up. "But there isn't any way to convey this same scarcity without imposing an austerity on our family that we worked really hard to avoid!" she says. Instead, Vanderkam decided that she wanted to teach her children to find work they love so they can earn money in a way that's meaningful to them. "I want them to live within their means, but I also know that sometimes you have to invest in things that matter," she adds.
Vanderkam also says it's useful to reflect on the money lessons your own parents taught you, and decide which habits you want to pass on (and which you don't). As a teen, Vanderkam launched her own summer day camp in her backyard, which taught her some entrepreneurial lessons she still applies, such as how to find customers. She wants her own children to similarly ask themselves, "How can I increase the amount of cash coming into my life?"
The T. Rowe Price survey also reveals that 43 percent of parents aren't sharing how worried they are about money, and 32 percent say they can't afford things when they actually can. That last one sounds like it could be a white lie, similar to telling a child there are no cookies left instead of telling him he can't have any more. But Ritter suggests that over time, those lies can have a detrimental effect, largely because parents miss out on the opportunities provided by such "teachable moments."
In fact, many parents have a rich source of topics to use as a jumping off point for family conversations about money: their own mistakes. Four in 10 parents said they regret not saving enough when they were younger, 1 in 3 said they regret overspending and building up debt, and 1 in 5 said they regret their choice of job or career. Even daily experiences such as a trip to the grocery store or ATM can lead to a discussion about trade-offs and choices.
That way, you can run down the chore list while also imparting lessons about saving and smart spending -- not bad for an otherwise lazy Saturday.
- Why Seeking More Money Hurts Happiness
- 11 Ways to Spring-Clean Your Finances
- Parents: Stop Being So Awkward With Money
- How to Hedge 7 Retirement Risks
- What Older Workers Don't Know About Social Security
- Why Americans are Delaying Retirement
- How to Avoid Being a Financial Burden on Your Children
- 6 Ways Spending Changes in Retirement
- Brainless Money Rules to Live By
- How to Break Up With Your Financial Adviser
- How to Help Family Members Without Hurting Your Own Finances
- Why Gen Y Is So Financially Frustrated
- The Key to Creating and Sticking to a Budget
- Daily Deal Websites Push Premium Memberships
- Want Free Checking? Ditch the Big Banks
- Ways to Donate to Charity on the Cheap
- Should Seniors Live Alone or With Family?
- How to Take Advantage of Dependents at Tax Time
- Effects of Recession Still Showing in Tax Season
- Why Money Really Can Buy Happiness
- 10 Things You Should Know About YourTaxes
- How to Save by Scavenging
- What's the Best Way to Give Money to Charity?
- Deja Vu? Bank of America Plans Fee Changes
- Got a Complaint About Your Bank?
- 5 Shocking Facts About Student Loan Debt
- Why the Smart Money Chooses a Roth IRA
- How to Protect Your Retirement Investments from Scams
- Smart Strategies for Taking Required Minimum Distributions
- Affordable Organic Foods for Every Budget
- Get Ready for Retirement Now
- How to Finance Life Until 100
- The Growing Challenge of Funding Retirement
- Tax Tips for Retirees
- How to Calculate Your Retirement Number
- How Long Should I Work Before Retirement?
- 10 Necessities for a Great Retirement Spot
- 10 Important Ages for Retirement Planning
- What Type of Life Insurance Do I Need?
- How to Save More Now With Savvy Budgeting
- 5 Apps for Organizing Your Expenses at Tax Time
- Banks Revamping Rewards Programs to Woo Customers
- How to Master the Art of Negotiation
- 5 Ways to Stretch Your Grocery Budget
- Sneaky Coupon Strategies Consumers Should Watch Out For
- How to Battle Shopping Addiction
- Starting Off on the Right Foot Financially
- Awkward Questions You Need to Ask Your Financial Adviser
- How to Avoid an IRS Audit
- 50 Ways to Improve Your Finances in 2012
- How to Set 2012 Money Goals That Work
- 2012: Financial Resolutions Beat Out Health and Fitness
- Time to Make New Year's Financial Resolutions
- How Retirement Savers Can Benefit from New 401(K) Fee Disclosures
- 12 Great Money Apps That Save Time and Cash
- How to Live Happily on Less
- Do You Need Longevity Insurance?
- Why Big Banks Are Like Drug Dealers
- 11 Retirement Benefit Changes Coming in 2012
- 10 Ways to Stay Safe While Shopping Online
- Take Advantage of Free Shipping Deals This Holiday Season
- Working Into Your 70s: A Smart Retirement Move
- How Co-Workers Influence Your 401(k) Choices
- How to Find the Best Bank Account for You
- How to Keep Your Holiday Spending in Check
- How To Navigate the Bank Fee Storm of 2011
- Santa on a Budget? What to Tell Your Kids
- Young Adults Suffering More Financially than Older Generations
- Borrowing From the Family Bank
Personal Finance - Parents: Stop Being So Awkward With Money
(c) 2012 U.S. News & World Report