The boy is in his bed crying because there's a monster in the room. Dad walks in, snaps on the light . . .
This is the setup for
Why, for God's sake, did I think of this cartoon when I read about the newly released Global Terrorism Index? Could it be that our childhood monsters -- which grown-ups call terrorists these days -- are being manipulated for political purposes?
This first-of-its-kind index, based on data collected by the
"In the decade since 9/11," according to the
In other words, this insane war is truly nothing less than a war to promote terror -- which was my term for the war from the start.
If we allow this data to suck all the humor out of Dator's cartoon, what we're left with is the grim reality of geopolitics: self-created monsters (which of course turn real) and a pile of skulls. The skulls represent the damage, collateral and otherwise, that we, the militarized First World nations, do in pursuit of our interests and our monsters.
And of course, as I've noted before, the definition of terrorism employed in the index is excruciatingly narrow: "illegal" use of force or violence by non-state actors to achieve a given end. Shock-and-awe bombing doesn't count, even though the entirety of its purpose is to terrorize a whole nation; assassination by drone doesn't count, even though armed drone surveillance paralyzes the normal social life of whole regions; and all the other overt and covert actions of state, from pre-emptive invasion to secretly orchestrated coup to the toxic and radioactive pollution of modern, high-tech, "legitimate" warfare don't count as terrorism, even though they disseminate terror in every direction.
I return to the documented reality that none of these efforts achieve their stated aim, any more than the "war on drugs" has accomplished anything except to exponentially expand the scope of the international drug problem.
But our wars do generate an endless supply of enemies (actual human beings who have a grievance against us) and monsters (imagined human beings who want only to commit evil against us). Thus, while the Global Terrorism Index documents the former, no one much, besides cartoonists, pays attention to the latter, unless you count soldiers and returning vets -- often diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder, i.e., a mental illness -- who are committing suicide at astonishing rates.
A couple months ago I wrote about the concept of "moral injury," which is a new, larger way of looking at PTSD, not as a mental illness but as the natural consequence of participating in the killing of human beings on command -- of violating a hardwired sense of human empathy.
Most of us lack a capacity to kill.
Stripped of the military context in which they did what they did, they were left alone with their consciences -- with the terrifying awareness that they had killed people. The pain of this was often intensified, for
To my mind, one of the most important implications of the breakthrough idea that conscience-wracked vets are dealing not with a "disorder" but with a moral injury, is that their condition is not isolated and individual but society-wide. Going to war is a collective decision and the consequences of doing so must also be borne collectively. But collectively we remain in denial, crying that there are monsters in the bedroom.
- Financial Nerve Centres at Risk of Flooding
- The Growth That Never Was
- A Gospel of Wealth
- Plutocrats: The Rise of the New Global Super Rich
- The Cyber Menace
- Cyber Threats: Establishing the First Line of Defense
- Arming The Information Highway Patrol
- Keeping the Global Ship on Course
- Global Governance at Heart of Failed Foreign Policies
- Global Terrorism: Piles of Skulls
- When Terrorists 'Killed' in Drone Strikes Aren't Really Dead
- Stripping Down to 140 Characters
- Revolution through iDemocracy
- Test Driving The Bamboo Bone Shaker
- What Tyrants Fear Most: Social Media
- Dambisa Moyo: 'Winner Take All'
- Nuclear Weapons Could Become Obsolete
- The Moral Equivalent of Nuremberg
- Rushdie: 'Vampires Shrivel in the Sunlight'
- Q&A with Joseph Stiglitz: 'The Price of Inequality'
- Children Often the Targets of Islamic Extremists
- Education Can Replace the Loss of Hope
- United Nations Picks Wrong Education Partners
- Testing the Limits of Globalization
- We're Too Tolerant of Corruption at Home
- No Need for a Witch Hunt Over Executive Pay
- Beyond Money
- 50-Year War Against Drugs Has Failed: A New Approach is Needed
- Drugs Legalization Could Make Things Worse
- Time to Separate Drugs Policy from Crime
- Organized Crime Won't Fade Away
- Is Treating The Symptoms The Way Forward?
- Heads of State Show Lack of Faith in Own Health-Care Systems
- On Drugs and Democracy
- Financial Markets, Politics and the New Reality
- BRICs Should Focus on their Own Problems
- The Persistent Threat to Soft Targets
- The Rich Grabbing Bigger Slices of Pie
- 21 Trillion Dollars Hidden in Tax Havens
(c) 2012 Tribune Media Services, Inc.