Over-Saving Caused the Economic Crisis
'Against Thrift's' James Livingston defends consumer culture while exploring the causes of the economic crisis
Why did you write this book?
The main motive I had was trying to figure out what happened [regarding the economic crisis] starting in 2006 or 2007. That is, I wrote a book on the Federal Reserve a long time ago and a lot of people sent me E-mails saying, you're an historian on banking, tell us what happened. And I thought, well, I am going to try.
What did you discover?
I realized these extraordinary inequalities in transfer income, from wages to profits or from labor to capital. I thought that was the key to thinking about the crisis and that of course took me back to the Great Depression. Once I had the comparison in place I could say to myself, and say to the world, the problem is over-saving, the problem is surplus capital.
Was the market over- or under-regulated?
I am not with the left in that I don't think re-regulation of the market is the answer. It's one answer, but it's not the answer. And on the right, this idea that government is the problem, I guess in theory it might make a little sense, but in practice, if you look at the history of the republic and the history of how growth is actually created, you realize that this has been a partnership, an interpenetration of public and private. You might even want to go as far as to say that it was interpenetration of the 20th century, in our own time, while capitalism is on the one hand and socialism on the other.
So the system is a blend of capitalism and socialism?
We're constantly trying to socialize markets, one way or another, because we are always talking about what kind of growth do we want, what kind of incomes should we have as Americans. In other words, what is the American standard of living supposed to look like, what could it be.
Is it dangerous to see the economy in ideological terms?
I think the private-public thing is really damaging to our thinking because since the 1790s, this synergistic, synthetic, symbiotic relationship between the public and the private has driven growth. Americans never thought it was an either-or until maybe the 1980s -- I am not sure even then. Right now it seems like we're there. I think the binary is dangerous.
What is the "politics of more"?
What [labor leader] Sam Gompers was always saying is that more income buys us more time, it buys us more leisure, it buys us more time away from work. And that's what I think what the politics of more is. That's why, when I talk about consumer culture, what I am trying to do is get us away from the idea that consumer culture is privatizing, this setting in which politics becomes pointless because we are all whacking away at our electronic devices.
You suggest that we can work less and produce more?
The history since 1919 proves that we can. Our problem is not production, our problem is distribution. Our problem is learning how to consume mindfully, and that too is a crucial part of politics of more. We can produce more with less labor, but then the question is, what do we want to produce? And what do we want to do with the free time that our extraordinary productive capacity gives us? How much can we do on behalf of others? And not because we are compassionate, it's because the distribution of capital is crucial for balanced growth.
What do you want to come out of the book?
I want this book to shake up the conventional wisdom. Let's see if we can create some fissures in the paradigm. The recession has taught us really fundamental lessons: The markets aren't self-regulating [and] transferring income from wages to profits does not produce more investment.
What are your thoughts on
I [recently] kicked off the march in front of
- Are We Entering a Jobless Recovery?
- GDP Growth Fastest Since Early 2010
- Good News and Bad News about GDP Growth
- Over-Saving Caused the Economic Crisis
- To Spur Economy, United States Must Reform Legal Immigration
- Immobility Nation
- United States 'Saudi Arabia of Natural Gas'
- Will Gas Prices Grow to $5 a Gallon?
- Fed Opens Up on Interest Rate, Inflation Predictions
- Obama to Save Economy With More Tourist Visas?
- Will Obama's Mortgage Refinance Plan Be D.O.A.?
- Top 5 Global Risks for 2012
- Lower Inflation Gives The Fed More Leeway in 2012
- What's in Store for Jobs in 2012?
- Our Challenge for 2012: Get Americans Working
- The Rebirth of Social Darwinism
- H-1B Workers in a State of Indentured Servitude
- Abuse of the H-1B Visa Program Is Widespread
- H-1B Visas a Symptom of Special-Interest Influence
- More Green Cards, Not H-1B Visas, Is the Real Fix
- We Are Creating a Dependency on H-1B Workers
- Unfilled Positions Reduce Productivity
- H-1Bs Are Simply Too Difficult to Get
- Most Immigrants Create Jobs
- White House Reiterates Urgency to Renew Payroll Tax Cut Bill
- Homegrown Obstacles to the Economic Recovery
- Does Extending Jobless Benefits Help the Economy?
- Men Continue To Fare Badly in This Economy
- Public Blames Congress, Not Obama, For Sour Economy
- Restore the Basic Bargain
- A Main Street Jobs Agenda
- Who Says Wall Street Isn't Hurting?
- Road Map to a Housing Rebound
- Housing Prices Drop Back to 2003 Levels
- GOP 2012 Candidates Split on Payroll Tax Cut
- We Need to Focus on the 99 Percent
- A More Permanent Solution Is Needed
- Keynesian Policies Have Failed
- Many Time-limited Tax Breaks Never Die
- A Strong Recovery Remains Elusive
- An Economic Loser in the Long Run
- Extending Payroll Tax Cut Will Extend U.S. Debt
- Jobs Report: A Glimmer of Hope for the Housing Market?
- Unemployment Rate Drops to 8.6 Percent
- Beige Book Shows Stronger Growth, but Europe a Major Threat
- What Happens If We End the Fed?
- Online Shopping Deals Hurt State Budgets
- 5 Reasons the Economy Will Be Better in 2012
Over-Saving Caused the Economic Crisis | Politics
Copyright 2012, U.S. News & World Report