Poverty Still America's Vicious Cycle
Why are some people stuck in poverty? Dr.
Payne is a poverty doc, or more aptly, a get-out-of-poverty doc. With a Ph.D. in educational leadership, she writes prescriptions for addressing the scourge of poverty wielded by public school systems, social service agencies and the corporate world. Her analysis is insightful, her advice practical, and it doesn't hurt that she has a delightful manner, which helps her bulldoze through the sensitive subjects of poverty, race, gender and class without ruffling feathers.
Payne says that people are poor due to their own behaviors and lack of education -- a rationale that appeals to political conservatives. Also, she thinks that political and economic structures keep people in poverty, even if they are hard-working, and that poor people are easily exploited -- ideas to which liberals nod their heads. All of these factors conspire to strip people in generational poverty of the stabilizing personal, economic and cultural resources they need to make it into the middle class.
Makes sense to me. Now what?
Payne asks if you've ever driven by a beaten up trailer and seen a new satellite dish outside. Do you know kids who qualify for free or reduced lunch but manage to have a dollar or two a day to spend on ice cream?
She says that people who can't understand these behaviors or are infuriated by them don't understand the hidden rules of poverty. For someone in generational poverty, it makes perfect sense to spend whatever money one possesses on a satellite dish or delicious ice cream. "Poverty is very painful," Payne says, "and money is used for entertainment to take away the pain."
Unlike people in the middle class who are driven by "work, achievement and material security," people in poverty are simply trying to get by day after day. The two chief drivers for the poor are entertainment and relationships, according to Payne. Entertainment is an escape from poverty's relentless tyranny, and relationships are a substitute for money as a survival strategy. When a middle-class person's car breaks down, they call AAA, Payne quips. When it happens to someone in poverty, they call Uncle Ray.
Only by understanding this mindset will teachers, social workers and employers succeed in connecting with people from generational poverty. As an example, Payne says that unless teachers are aware of how relationships have paramount value for an at-risk child, they won't understand the need to create a trusting, mutually respectful connection with him or her. Otherwise, the child will refuse to learn from them.
Payne came to be an expert on poverty almost by accident. She was working for a public school district in
Personally, I agree with much of her analysis, including her claim that simply having more money won't change the culture of the poor -- lottery winners prove that. But I think Payne underplays the benefits of a living wage and how transformational that alone can be.
It's exhausting to be poor. You may have to work more than one job, use spotty public transit and rely on undependable child care arrangements. Children of the poor are often thrust into the role of taking care of younger siblings or shouldering other adult duties. Had
Payne's work is undeniably needed. Making every job in America a good job by raising the minimum wage to a living wage is needed more.
- Economic Strategy for Better Jobs, Not Just Higher Profits
- Fast-food Workers Echo Occupy Spirit
- Inside the Superstar Economy of America's Big Thinkers
- The Real Economy: The Weather is Still Stormy
- Family Values and the New Economy
- The Nation-State and the Global Corporation
- A Good-Paying Job More Effective than a Lecture
- The Rich Life or the Good Life?
- The Economic Elephant in the Room: Widening Inequality
- Austerity Leaves Us Crying '96 Tears'
- Capitalism Is Not Dying
- Banking on the Poor
- Tracking CEO Pay
- The Stealth Sequester
- Half-Baked Economic Theories Continue to Direct Global Economy
- Why There's a Bull Market for Investors and a Bear Market for Workers
- The Contest Over Defining Our Biggest Economic Problem
- A Shortage of Mercy
- The Minimum Wage and The Meaning of a Decent Society
- The Hoax of Austerity Economics
- The Non-Zero-Sum Society
- Raising the Minimum Wage Would Boost Economy
- Poverty Still America's Vicious Cycle
- Government Spending That Isn't Smart
- Time to Break Up the Biggest Wall Street Banks
- Report Highlights Economic Threat of Hacking
- The Hoax of 'Entitlement Reform'
- Grow the Economy by Growing the Debate About It
- The Great Decoupling
- Why We Must Stop Obsessing About the Budget Deficit
- Christmas-Shopping Season Highlights Plight of Retail Workers
- The Holiday Shopping Guide for Hard Times
- The 'Land of Opportunity' is Becoming Hollywood Fiction
- The Fiscal Cliff: False Fears and Horrors
- Another Side of Economic Inequality
- Don't Cut Our Kids Out of the Budget
- Republicans and Democrats Playing Game of Economic Chicken
- The Trojan Horse in the Debt Debate
- The Dead-End Servant Economy
- Q&A with Joseph Stiglitz: 'The Price of Inequality'
Poverty Still America's Vicious Cycle | Economy
(c) 2013 Tribune Media Services, Inc.