Why Did We Forget Important Economic Lessons?
by Robert B. Reich
Why has America forgotten the three most important economic lessons we learned in the 30 years following World War II?
Before I answer that question, let me remind you what those lessons were:
First, America's real job creators are consumers, whose rising wages generate jobs and growth. If average people don't have decent wages, there can be no real recovery and no sustained growth.
In those years, business boomed because American workers were getting raises and had enough purchasing power to buy what expanding businesses had to offer. Strong labor unions had ensured that American workers got a fair share of the economy's gains. It was a virtuous cycle.
Second, the rich do better with a smaller share of a rapidly growing economy than they do with a large share of an economy that's barely growing at all.
Between 1946 and 1974, the economy grew faster than it has grown since, on average, because the nation was creating the largest middle class in history. The overall size of the economy doubled, as did the earnings of almost everyone. CEOs rarely took home more than 40 times the average worker's wage, yet they were riding high.
Third, higher taxes on the wealthy to finance public investments -- better roads, bridges, public transportation and basic research, plus world-class K-12 education and affordable higher education -- improve the future productivity of America. All of us gain from these investments, including the wealthy.
In those years, the top marginal income tax rate on America's highest earners never fell below 70 percent. Under Republican President
We learned, in other words, that broadly shared prosperity isn't just compatible with a healthy economy. It's essential to it.
But then we forgot these lessons. For the last three decades the American economy has continued to grow, but most people's earnings have gone nowhere. Since the start of the recovery in 2009, 95 percent of the gains have gone to the top 1 percent.
Many of us bought the snake oil of "supply-side" economics, which said big corporations and the wealthy are the job creators -- and if we cut their taxes, the benefits will trickle down to everyone else. But nothing trickled down.
Meanwhile, big corporations were allowed to bust labor unions, whose membership dropped from over a third of all private-sector workers in the 1950s to under 7 percent today.
Our roads and bridges were allowed to crumble under the weight of deferred maintenance, our public schools deteriorated, and public higher education became so starved for funds that tuition rose to make up for shortfalls, making college unaffordable to many working families.
Part of the reason for this extraordinary U-turn has to do with politics. As income and wealth concentrated at the top, so did political power. The captains of industry and of
But why didn't they remember the lessons learned in the 30 years after World War II -- that broadly shared prosperity is good for everyone, including them?
Perhaps because wealth is also relative. How rich someone feels depends not just on how much money they have but also on how they live in comparison to most other people.
As the gap between America's wealthy and the middle has widened, those at the top have felt even richer by comparison. Although a rising tide would lift all boats, many of America's richest seem to prefer a lower tide and bigger yachts.
- Calling Working People of All Colors
- Exploding Inequality is Killing Democracy
- Reducing Inequality in the Trump Era
- Obama's Legacy: Growth, Debt & Employment
- Only 5 Countries Have A Bigger GDP Than California
- Global Political Economy
- How The Global Millionaire Club Is Changing
- Plenty of Dough in Online Food Delivery
- The Most Expensive Metro Areas to Live In
- Cities With the Lowest Gas Prices
- The Cost of a Beer: Then and Now
- The Cost of a Cup of Coffee: Then and Now
- Cities Where Coffee Costs the Most
- America's Decreasing Fertility Rate Could Spell Economic Trouble
- The Least Affordable Places for Single Parents
- How the Cost of a Movie Ticket Has Changed Over Time
- The Cost of a Trip to the Emergency Room Since 1940
- Gagging on the Gig Economy
- How Falling Oil Prices Have Changed the Economy
- The Economics of Brexit
- Making China Great Again
- States with the Lowest Unemployment Rates
- Oil's Downfall Aided by Rise of Fracking
- Counties Where Medicare Spends the Most per Patient
- Inequality Will Get Worse Until There's a Revolution
- States with the Highest Unemployment Rates
- The Richest Banks
- Cost Of a Car Since 1967
- Cost of Car Insurance In Every State
- The Most Fuel Efficient Cars
- Zombie Ideas and the Death of Ethics in Economics
- What Really Caused the Eurozone Crisis?
- Is GDP Over?
- Pay Fair or Pay Up
- Global Capitalism's Latest Crisis
- Gross National Happiness Catches On
- The Cutting Edge of Waste
- Subsidizing the Idle Rich While Poor Kids Go Hungry
- Lending Dreams
- Venture Capitalists Rule the World
- National Debt Over $18 Trillion
- Will ECB Quantitative Easing Work?
- NYC Mayor for Pay at $13 an Hour
- U.S. Banks Pass Stress Test
- Vanguard's 2015 Global Economic Outlook
- Wal-Mart Does Something Right
- The Perils of America's Hard-Charging Capitalism
- Freedom Summer II
- Economy Looking Up, But Politics Stuck in Neutral
- Money and Morality: The Parallel Between Energy and Slavery
- The Four Biggest Right-Wing Lies About Inequality
- Proposal to Keep CEO Pay in Check
- Antitrust Laws Potentially Useful in New Gilded Age
- If We Raise Minimum Wage, Why Stop at $10 an Hour?
- The 'You're Paid What You're Worth' Myth
- The Great U-turn
- 'The Grapes of Wrath' Resonates 75 Years Later
- International Money Is International Politics
- The New Politics of International Currencies
- The Real Job Killers: Lousy Jobs, Lousy Wages
- Take Tax Compromise with a Grain of Salt
- WhatsApp Deal Shines Light on Our Economic Problems
- Why Did We Forget Important Economic Lessons?
- Why There's No Outcry Over Economic Inequality
- The Year of the Great Wealth Redistribution
- Fear is Why Workers Vote Against Their Economic Self-Interest
- Free the Keystone XL Pipeline, Mr. President
- Gender Pay Equity: Yeah, It's Still A Problem
- Income 'Inequality'
- Why the Right Should Support Boosting Minimum Wage, Too
- Coming to Grips with Rise of the Machines
- Detroit's Decline Did Not Have to Happen
- The Roaring Twenties Are Back
- Predistribute the Wealth
- Global Shipping Contends with Oversupply Problems
- Runaway CEO Pay Gets a Free Pass
- Exceptionally Mediocre on a Global Scale
- A More Perfect Union
- Economic Strategy for Better Jobs, Not Just Higher Profits
- Fast-food Workers Echo Occupy Spirit
- Inside the Superstar Economy of America's Big Thinkers
- The Real Economy: The Weather is Still Stormy
- Family Values and the New Economy
- The Nation-State and the Global Corporation
- A Good-Paying Job More Effective than a Lecture
- The Rich Life or the Good Life?
- The Economic Elephant in the Room: Widening Inequality
Article: Copyright © 2016, Tribune Content Agency.
"Why Did We Forget Important Economic Lessons?"