After Orlando: Twitter Recoils from Islamophobia, Takes Aim at Gun Laws
by Saif Shahin
An analysis of the Twitter conversation over 12 hours on the day of the shooting reveals deep animosity against politicians for not legislating tougher gun controls.
Twitter users responded to the shooting in Orlando, Florida, with an abundance of love and prayers for the victims, their families, and the gay community in America, fury against political leaders for failing to institute stricter gun controls -- and very little by way of Islamophobia despite the shooter's Muslim identity and apparent allegiance to the Islamic State (ISIS or IS).
Forty-nine people were killed and nearly an equal number injured when Omar Mateen, a U.S.-born national of Afghan origin, opened fire at a gay nightclub in the wee hours of Sunday. The body count made it one of the worst incidents of mass shooting on American soil.
The response to the tragedy on Twitter was immediate and massive. I mined all tweets with the hashtag #Orlando beginning just before noon Eastern Time on Sunday -- soon after the shooter's identity was publicly revealed. Over the next 12 hours, I collected a total of 50,000 tweets divided into five batches of 10,000 each. Every batch spans roughly two-and-a-half hours of Twitter activity. I then analyzed these tweets to understand how the Twitter conversation evolved over the course of the day using a computerized technique called Topic Modeling, which breaks down large textual datasets into groups of keywords representing different "topics" of conversation.
Five broad "topics" regarding the Orlando shooting emerged from the analysis.
Guns N' Roses
The first topic, which dominated Twitter all through the day, includes the keywords "orlando," "victims," "shooting," "people," "prayers," "loveislove," "love," "thoughts," "hate," "families," "lgbt," "gun," "gay," "america," and "obama." I label this topic Guns N' Roses (see Figure 1). These keywords indicate that this topic focuses on the act of the shooting itself along with messages of love and prayers for its victims, their families, and the gay community. For example, one tweet read: "Our hearts break for the victims and families of this horrific act of violence. We stand in solidarity with the LGBTQ community #Orlando #LoveIsLove."
The presence of the keyword "gun" in this topic suggests that Twitter users saw the tragedy as yet another instance of unrestrained gun violence in America. One such tweet read: "Not sure what to think about #Orlando except in 2016 we still not safe. LGBT legislation doesn't keep us safe, gun laws don't keep us safe." The keywords also suggest that President Obama's speech after the shooting was frequently commented upon. Although users were mostly supportive of the president's pro-gun control message, many pointed out that he has delivered the same message after every tragedy but has failed to act on his own words.
Although Guns N' Roses dominated the Twitter conversation all through the day, it proportionally declined in use from above 70 percent between noon and 4:40 pm to about 50 percent after 9.30 pm (see Figure 1).
The IS (Dis)Connect
The second biggest topic of conversation varied in almost each of the five batches of tweets collected (see Figure 2). Between noon and 2:20 pm, the second biggest topic (28 percent of Twitter conversation) included the keywords "ISIS," "Pakistan," "kamalfaridi," and "violence." This was soon after the media revealed the shooter's name, and his Muslim identity featured prominently in tweets.
A casual look at the topic may suggest an upsurge of Islamophobia in this period, and indeed there were several tweets that linked Mateen's action to Islam and to blaming Muslims as a community. But a large number of tweets also pointed out the folly of such an attitude. One tweet, for instance, read: "Whether this was ISIS or not, to respond with hate and prejudice is exactly what they want. To alienate Muslims around the world. #Orlando." Therefore, I label this topic The IS (Dis)Connect.
Several Twitter users retweeted a post by the user @KamalFaridi that read "Our heart goes out to the victims and families in #Orlando. Love and peace can never be extinguished. #Pakistan #Muslims." Others questioned how, despite Mateen's known IS sympathies, he could be allowed to purchase guns--thus putting the blame once again on U.S. gun laws rather than IS or Muslims per se. A commonly retweeted post, by journalist Piers Morgan, read: "FBI interviewed this guy TWICE about ISIS sympathies but he could still legally buy his guns 2 weeks ago???? Unbelievable."
Art Versus Politics
In the next two-and-a-half-hours or so, that is until 4:40 pm, the second most prominent topic of Twitter conversation (22 percent) included keywords such as "tonyawards," "politicians," "fifa," "gaysbreaktheinternet," "action," "egnjyd," "endgunviolence," "everytown," "prayfortheworld," and "ecuvhai." Much of this conversation hailed the art world's response to Orlando. The Tony Awards for theatrical performances, held on Sunday, came in for special praise in tweets such as "'Hamilton' cast won't use musket props in #TonyAwards performance after #Orlando shootings" and "Silver ribbons at @TheTonyAwards in observance of #orlando."
Many users retweeted Lady Gaga calling on followers to donate to the Pulse Victims Fund ("egnjyd" was part of the link to the fund's website). The minute of silence observed during Sunday's soccer match between Ecuador and Haiti ("ECUvHAI") was also frequently tweeted about.
Many tweets contrasted the response of the art and sports world with that of politicians. This common refrain was reflected in retweets of user @Everytown's post: "We need more than thoughts & prayers from our politicians to #EndGunViolence. America needs action. #Orlando." Another user posted, "Hard to take seriously these #Orlando 'solidarity' tweets from politicians + religious leaders who've fought the LBGTQ community for years."
This topic became the second most dominant in the next two batches of tweets-- from 4:40 pm to 7 pm (21 percent) and from 7 pm to 9:30 pm (38 percent). It included keywords such as "victims," "vigil," "love," "center," "lit," "trade," "colors," "rainbow," "prayfororlando," "tonight," "trump," "listen," "cut," "world," and "watch."
As these keywords suggest, the Twitter conversation over these five hours prominently featured vigils being organized around the world to pray for the victims. A user from Toronto, for instance, tweeted: "Heading to the vigil for #Orlando. I need to be with other folks who have felt afraid they might get killed just for being who they are." Several users also posted about 1 World Trade Center being lit with the colors of the pride flag to honor victims.
Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump's announcement that he had been warning the nation against the dangers of "Islamic terrorism" was another prominent trope within The Vigil. It was both praised and panned. Although supporters insisted that Trump was the only leader who could keep terrorists at bay, detractors such as @thelittleidiot posted, "Shame on you @realDonaldTrump trying to use the heartbreak and tragedy in #orlando for your political gain."
Author J.K. Rowling, of Harry Potter fame, tweeted that one of the Orlando victims had been a member of the film crew. She posted: "Luis Vielma worked on the Harry Potter ride at Universal. He was 22 years old. I can't stop crying. #Orlando." Twitter users retweeted her extensively and Vielma's death became the second most dominant topic of conversation (42 percent) from 9:30 pm until midnight, including the keywords "orlando," "worked," "universal," "luis," "harry," "potter," "years," "jk," "crying," "rowling," "vielma," "ride," and "stop." It closely trailed Guns N' Roses, which was still the most dominant topic at 50 percent.
To the extent that the Twitter conversation represents the public mood in the wake of the shooting, the trends identified here have three important implications. First, the prevalence of Guns N' Roses as the dominant topic all through the day indicates that Americans keenly desire more gun control. Public opinion polls have indicated that a majority of Americans are tired of the influence the pro-gun lobby wields over lawmaking: the Twitter reaction to Orlando reinforces this finding.
Second, despite Mateen's Muslim identity, Americans are largely unwilling to give in to Islamophobia in the wake of this tragedy. Mateen's Muslim faith and IS allegiance was discussed briefly and in a fairly balanced manner on Twitter, and then the conversation moved on to other topics. This absence of anti-Muslim animosity is especially notable as it follows months of efforts to ramp up the fear of and hatred for Muslims during this election cycle.
Third, if Twitter users displayed any animosity, it was toward their political leaders who do not reform gun laws despite repeated tragedies. This sentiment came up again and again in various topics of conversation over the course of the day. Even users who noted Mateen's IS link remarked that, his motivation aside, it was eventually their leaders' failure to tighten gun control that allowed him to purchase assault rifles.
Saif Shahin is a doctoral candidate in the School of Journalism, University of Texas at Austin. He studies news and international politics, and previously worked as a journalist in India, England, and the Middle East.
- Clinton Regains Lead
- How Much Candidates Spent Per Vote
- Tim Kaine Cheat Sheet
- Mike Pence by the Numbers
- Americans Divided on Bathroom Bill
- Clinton's Stubborn 75 Percent Chance Finally Dips Following Email Revelations
- The 2016 Democratic Convention by the Numbers
- The 2016 Republican Convention by the Numbers
- Trump's Fundraising Turnaround: June Marked Best Month So Far
- Trump Captures His Largest Lead So Far in Polls
- Trump Pulls Ahead of Clinton in Key Swing States
- Donald Trump and America B
- House Sit-In Would've Been More Powerful if It Rejected 'No Fly, No Buy'
- Clinton's Foreign Policy Poses a Challenge to the Left
- Hillary Wants to Bring Back Bill. She Shouldn't
- The Real Reason Republicans Are Going after the IRS
- ISIS Must Love Trump
- Can Trump Ride the Anti-Immigration Wave to the White House?
- Trouble for Donald Trump's Campaign
- America's Most Followed Members of Congress
- Hillary Clinton's Major Foreign Policy Address Was Anything But
- Donald Trump Down in the Polls After Rough Week on the Trail
- There's No More Denying It: Trump Is Openly Racist
- Donald Trump: Joker's Wild
- After Orlando: Twitter Recoils from Islamophobia, Takes Aim at Gun Laws
- How Much Blame Should Hillary Clinton Bear for Libya?
- Countries That Receive the Most Foreign Aid From the U.S.
- Hillary Clinton Secures Democratic Nomination
- Welcome to Half Dome, Sponsored by Nike
- Companies Need to Stop Bankrolling Hate
- For Billionaire Donors, Academic Integrity Comes Cheap
- America's Cosmic Tax Gap
- Trump's 'Realty Check' on Climate
- Putin and Trump: Symptoms of Creeping Caesarism
- Obama Promised Open Government, But Hasn't Delivered Yet
- A Coalition of the Unhinged
- Putting Free Speech Out to Pasture
- The Only Sane Conclusion from Orlando
- Orlando Shooting Fuels Debate on Gun Control
- They're Killing Us. Help Us Stop Them
- A Commencement Address for the Most Indebted Class Ever
- Our Poverty Myth
- Which States Have Banned Assault Weapons?
- Government Agencies that Spend the Most
- The Government Agencies that Employ the Most People
- Odd Ways Political Campaigns Spend Their Money
- Congressional Districts with the Youngest and Oldest Voters
- Trump Nabs First Lead Against Clinton in Poll
- Bernie's Bucks: Sanders' Fundraising and Spending Prowess in 5 Charts
- Clinton Holds Razor-Thin Lead
- Doling Out the Dough for Pro-Clinton Super PACs
- States with the Most Women in Politics
- Do First Ladies Influence the Popularity of Baby Names?
- Counties Where Medicare Spends the Most per Patient
- We Live in a Democracy, Not a Theocracy
- Is Trump an American Exceptionalist?
- Sanders vs Clinton on Economic Inequality
- Big Money in Politics Drives War
- Why Clinton Supports the Trans-Pacific Partnership and Trump Does Not
Politics: "After Orlando: Twitter Recoils from Islamophobia, Takes Aim at Gun Laws"