A Crack in the School-Choice Dike
Few organizations are as consistently liberal as the
Which makes it remarkable that the executive committee of ADL's Philadelphia chapter has voted overwhelmingly in favor of a resolution endorsing vouchers that would allow children in underperforming schools in poor neighborhoods to escape to schools that would give them a safer environment in which to learn and, thus, a better education.
Attempts to improve public schools by having them compete for students with a choice as to which educational institution they will attend -- in Philadelphia and elsewhere -- have been faced with consistent opposition from teachers unions and Democratic politicians who care more about patronage and union contributions than the overall welfare of children.
The Philadelphia ADL letter reads like a legal argument with mounds of facts in support of its position. It says, "The evidence that our public education system is failing to educate our children is staggering ... high rates of illiteracy, an unacceptable number of high school dropouts and the widening achievement gap between white and minority students merely scratch the surface."
The letter backs up what conservatives have been saying for years: "Despite dramatically increasing the amount of money spent on K-12 education over the past several decades -- per pupil expenditures have increased by 53.6 percent (after adjusting for inflation) -- student performance is abysmal."
Read that again: "student performance is abysmal." Not flat, or slowly improving, but abysmal!
Addressing what it says is a "common myth that school-voucher programs drain financial resources, as well as the best and brightest students from public schools," the letter says, "the evidence proves otherwise. Research on voucher programs' effects on the finances of public schools shows that these programs actually save money at both the state and local level. Furthermore, as a recent study by the (liberal)
The ADL letter says nine major studies on the systemic effects of vouchers on public schools found positive effects on public schools: "...school-choice programs complement public education by spurring the public system, as a result of competition, to perform better. No study has found that school choice makes public schools worse."
Liberals have been on the wrong side of this issue for years. Conservatives have demonstrated their superior "compassion" by favoring vouchers that would allow poor children the best chance to climb out of poverty and not repeat their parents' mistakes. If Republicans can't win with this issue by attracting more minority voters with children in failing schools, they don't deserve to remain a viable political party.
In 2002, the
Available at Amazon.com:
Read the latest political news.
- Do Great Leaders Make History or Are They Carried Along by the Tides of Change
- The Learning Curve of Peace
- Financial Reform's Uncertain Promise
- Election Day: The Calm Between Two Storms
- Election Day: The Morning After
- How the Tea Party Brings Back the 1960s
- The Republicans' Tea Party Problem
- 2010 Elections: A Warning to Incumbents
- Specter and Critz Results Send Mixed Messages for Democrats
- 2010 Elections: Violating a Cardinal Rule of Politics
- The Crippling Price of Public Employee Unions
- Obama: Over the Rainbows
- Left Right and Wrong
- Rand Paul: Radical Rookie
- BP Oil Spill: And a Child Shall Lead Them
- Texas State Board of Education: Textbook Wars
- A Crack in the School-Choice Dike
- To the Graduates
- Toxic Talk: Poison in the Air
- Congress Looks for Answers After Gulf Oil Spill
- Gulf Oil Spill Has High Stakes for Obama
- Why Republicans Will Win in the 2010 Elections
- Hot Races to Watch This Fall
- Top Fundraising Senate Campaigns
- Top Fundraising House Campaigns
- Self-Funded Candidates Make Waves in 2010 Senate Election Races
- Female Corporate Executives Shaking Things up in Political Races
- Voters See Debt Crisis. Why Doesn't Washington?
- Democrats Game Plan: Play Offense
- Can Obama Save Democratic Party
- Money Could Decide 2010 Midterm Elections
- First Lady's Popularity Could Give Boost to Administration's Agenda
- Pure Parties Are Losing Parties
- Clear Principles Win Elections
- Obama's Political Dream Team
- Tea Party Movement Could Help or Hurt Republicans
- Mapping a New GOP Majority
- Elena Kagan: Obama's Pragmatic Court Choice
- 10 Things You Didn't Know About Elena Kagan
- Afghanistan: Papering Over Afghan Woes
- Slipping a Mickey to California Democrats
- The Robert Bennett Message
- I've Been Thinking About Women in Government
- Why Politicians Should Lie
- Politics, Always Politics
- Still the Optimist
- Living with Risk is the Cost of Freedom
- Naysaying Anti-Terrorism Success
- Sounds of Insecurity
- The Death of the Tea Party Movement
- Life in the Age of 'Much Worse Than We Thought It Would Be'
- Guns vs. Butter 2010
A Crack in the School-Choice Dike | Politics
(c) 2010 Cal Thomas