Missing in Action: Political Reality and Leadership (Photo: Keith Ellison / Flickr)
by Ryan Alexander
Every federal budget is a dream sheet. They’re all unrealistic.
It goes something like this: The president lays out a slate of new programs, revenue raisers, and strategic cuts. Then Republican leaders pull out their X-Acto knives, highlighting cuts to programs they oppose. Then the more conservative caucuses sing, with apologies to Irving Berlin, “whatever they can cut, I can cut better.”
But budgets also serve real purposes. They dictate how much money can be spent in a given year, give directions on how to prioritize that spending, and draw a vision for how to move into the future.
It’s natural to expect some posturing in the budget process. But this year, every single budget starts with unrealistic assumptions that the other side will never agree to. The focus is all vision and politics. Utility is ignored.
President Barack Obama’s request, for example, assumes massive increases in infrastructure spending, a rollback of special interest tax breaks, the passage of immigration reform, and no major changes to deal with the fiscal challenges facing Social Security and Medicare. All told, it claims to produce $3.64 trillion in savings over 10 years.
But Congress has already said it won't enact these policies. In fact, many of the same ideas were rejected in the last budget -- and, in the case of certain tax breaks, in every one of Obama's budgets. Why would this change in an election year?
The House's proposed budget also turns a blind eye to political reality. To amass its $7 trillion in savings over a decade, it repeals the Affordable Care Act, aka Obamacare ($2 trillion), and makes structural changes to Medicaid ($1 trillion). It also cuts -- and then freezes for nine years -- all non-military spending ($887 billion), while increasing Pentagon expenditures every year.
Even with low inflation, the idea that Washington will go several years without spending one more dime on government outside the Pentagon is laughable. Whether you like it or not, the likelihood that Obama will make one of his last acts as president repealing his signature health care legislation is less than nil.
House conservatives go even further, claiming that their budget would save taxpayers $8.6 trillion over the next decade.
Faced with all these competing budget proposals, it looks like the budget and appropriations train is about to derail without leaving the station.
The conservative House Freedom Caucus has raised objections to $1.07 trillion top-line spending level in the standard-issue House budget -- preferring the $1.04 trillion originally included in the Budget Control Act of 2011 instead. Senate leaders want to stick with the $1.07 trillion figure, though they may not even produce a budget resolution. House Speaker Paul Ryan says it's $1.07 trillion or bust.
All signs point to another “omnibus” spending bill, negotiated behind closed doors in the House speaker’s office, to close out Obama’s last year in office.
It doesn't have to be this way.
As budgets are political documents, there will always be some disagreements. But the gulf between Congress and the president, between Republicans and Democrats, the House and the Senate, and even within the House Republican majority ranks is only getting larger. There are plenty of ideas that could find bipartisan agreement, but everybody’s talking past each other.
What we really need is leadership. Budgeting based on politics, accounting gimmicks, and the legislative equivalent of putting your opponent between a rock and a hard place hasn’t worked.
We need lawmakers who are willing to step up, consider the national interest, and say no -- my parochial project isn't the most important thing today. We need folks who will put it all on the line to tackle the big issues facing our country.
We may all be watching the circus in the presidential primary, but the show in Congress is just as ridiculous.
Ryan Alexander is president of Taxpayers for Common Sense, a nonpartisan federal budget watchdog. www.taxpayer.net.
More AMERICAN POLITICS ...
- Clinton Regains Lead
- How Much Candidates Spent Per Vote
- Tim Kaine Cheat Sheet
- Mike Pence by the Numbers
- Americans Divided on Bathroom Bill
- Clinton's Stubborn 75 Percent Chance Finally Dips Following Email Revelations
- The 2016 Democratic Convention by the Numbers
- The 2016 Republican Convention by the Numbers
- Trump's Fundraising Turnaround: June Marked Best Month So Far
- Trump Captures His Largest Lead So Far in Polls
- Trump Pulls Ahead of Clinton in Key Swing States
- Donald Trump and America B
- House Sit-In Would've Been More Powerful if It Rejected 'No Fly, No Buy'
- Clinton's Foreign Policy Poses a Challenge to the Left
- Hillary Wants to Bring Back Bill. She Shouldn't
- The Real Reason Republicans Are Going after the IRS
- ISIS Must Love Trump
- Can Trump Ride the Anti-Immigration Wave to the White House?
- Trouble for Donald Trump's Campaign
- America's Most Followed Members of Congress
- Hillary Clinton's Major Foreign Policy Address Was Anything But
- Donald Trump Down in the Polls After Rough Week on the Trail
- There's No More Denying It: Trump Is Openly Racist
- Donald Trump: Joker's Wild
- After Orlando: Twitter Recoils from Islamophobia, Takes Aim at Gun Laws
- How Much Blame Should Hillary Clinton Bear for Libya?
- Countries That Receive the Most Foreign Aid From the U.S.
- Hillary Clinton Secures Democratic Nomination
- Welcome to Half Dome, Sponsored by Nike
- Companies Need to Stop Bankrolling Hate
- For Billionaire Donors, Academic Integrity Comes Cheap
- America's Cosmic Tax Gap
- Trump's 'Realty Check' on Climate
- Putin and Trump: Symptoms of Creeping Caesarism
- Obama Promised Open Government, But Hasn't Delivered Yet
- A Coalition of the Unhinged
- Putting Free Speech Out to Pasture
- The Only Sane Conclusion from Orlando
- Orlando Shooting Fuels Debate on Gun Control
- They're Killing Us. Help Us Stop Them
- A Commencement Address for the Most Indebted Class Ever
- Our Poverty Myth
- Which States Have Banned Assault Weapons?
- Government Agencies that Spend the Most
- The Government Agencies that Employ the Most People
- Odd Ways Political Campaigns Spend Their Money
- Congressional Districts with the Youngest and Oldest Voters
- Trump Nabs First Lead Against Clinton in Poll
- Bernie's Bucks: Sanders' Fundraising and Spending Prowess in 5 Charts
- Clinton Holds Razor-Thin Lead
- Doling Out the Dough for Pro-Clinton Super PACs
- States with the Most Women in Politics
- Do First Ladies Influence the Popularity of Baby Names?
- Counties Where Medicare Spends the Most per Patient
- We Live in a Democracy, Not a Theocracy
- Is Trump an American Exceptionalist?
- Sanders vs Clinton on Economic Inequality
- Nine Lessons for Navigating National Security
- Trumped Up Alliances?
- Big Money in Politics Drives War
- Why Clinton Supports the Trans-Pacific Partnership and Trump Does Not
- The Trans-Pacific Partnership and the 2016 US Presidential Election
- Obama: The Conflict Resolution President?
- Bernie Sanders Still the 2016 Fundraising Champ
- Inequality Will Get Worse Until There's a Revolution
- Crime Can Pay if It's Big Enough
- Political Campaigns May Put Your Personal Data at Risk
- Fear, Anger and Attitudes Toward Immigration
- The New (Anti-)Secularism
- Clinton, Trump Poised for Northeastern Sweep on Tuesday
- Trump's Bad Ideas Aren't Un-American After All
- The Death Gap
- Why Trump Is No Longer a Safe Bet
- 22 People, $43 Million: The People Doling Out the Dough for Pro-Clinton Super PACs
- It's Literally Impossible to Deport 11 Million Immigrants
- Here's What a Budget That Prioritizes Peace Looks Like
- Does the Military Support Trump?
- Where Are the Wealthiest Voters?
- How the Pentagon Wastes Your Money
- This Election, We Can't Afford to Ignore the Climate
- The Children's Crusade
- When Islam Polices Extremists
- Hillary Clinton's State Department Armed Saudi Arabia to the Teeth
- Free From Jail, Imprisoned by Debt
- American Cities Most at Risk of Zika Virus
- Operation Paul Ryan
- What Trumpism Means for Democracy
- Trump Opens Floodgates of Hate
- Missing in Action: Political Reality and Leadership
- Give 'Tax and Spend' a Chance
- Donald Trump: Foreign Policy's Useful Idiot?
- When Red Tape Is a Good Thing
- Trump Holds Strong Lead in New York, Clinton-Sanders Race Tightens
- These States Give the Most Money to the Presidential Race
- The Most Influential Presidential Power Couples
- The Most Influential First Ladies
- Wall Street Should Pay a Sales Tax, Too
- Cruz, Not Trump, Has Shot to Beat Clinton
- Republicans Who Really Don't Like Donald Trump
- What Would Nancy Reagan Say?
- The Humpty Dumpty Party
- What Are Trump's Values -- and America's?
- Primary Trends: Media Goes Crazy, Bettors Yawn
- Most Liberal Members of Congress
- Most Conservative Members of Congress
- 25 Facts About Abraham Lincoln
- 25 Facts About John F. Kennedy
- Marco Rubio Is Winning the Neocon Primary
- Obama: The Fairy-Tale President?
- Terrorism & Trump: New Challenges for Social Justice Organizations
- How Sky-High CEO Pay Pollutes Our Planet and Our Politics
- Foucault's Analytic of Power
- The Cliché of Civilizations
- Religious Politics & Illiberal Religion
- Endless War, Undeclared and Undebated
- Bernie Sanders Has America Talking About Denmark
- Paul Ryan vs the People
Article: Distributed by OtherWords.org.
"Missing in Action: Political Reality and Leadership"