Obama's Inaugural Address Not Progressive Enough
It was a liberal speech by a liberal president. That sums up the commentariat's assessment of President
But Obama's speech didn't satisfy liberal longings in some key respects. He failed to defend unions and civil liberties, and without those elements, Obama is not going to succeed in putting the country back on a positive progressive track. Maybe he will make amends next month during the State of the Union address, but I doubt it.
Unions went unmentioned because while Obama, a former community organizer, may understand the role that collective action plays in political movements, he doesn't seem to appreciate how essential it is in granting people power over the conditions of their work.
Civil liberties went missing because Obama has failed miserably in delivering on his 2009 inaugural promise to reject "the choice between our safety and our ideals." On due process for terror suspects, domestic wiretapping and transparency, Obama has been only marginally better than his predecessor, if at all.
First, on unions. In his speech, Obama singled out the great historical civil rights events at
As part of his declared national credo, which did emphasize that prosperity must rest "upon the broad shoulders of a rising middle class," Obama should have credited labor unions for having once turned that hope into reality.
Here are the facts: From the 1940s to the 1970s, when unionization rates were at their peak, real wages rose in tandem with productivity gains, resulting in an expansive middle class. As union rates have declined, so have workers' economic prospects. And don't blame globalization or technology. Other developed countries, such as
Obama showed how little he understood about the importance of unions to his stated goal of reducing income inequality when he didn't vocally object to the right-to-work measures in
On civil liberties, the administration's record has been equally disappointing for liberals. Obama recently signed the National Defense Authorization Act which constrains his ability to close Guantanamo, something he promised to do four years ago.
Obama has not abated the use of the state secrets defense to hide the misdeeds of the CIA during the Bush years. He has prevented innocent victims of torture from obtaining justice and the country from learning exactly what was done in our name.
Last year, he signed the FISA Amendments Act Reauthorization, which extended for another five years the warrantless wiretapping program by the
And Obama's use of drones to target and kill even American citizens abroad without any legal review is a dangerous expansion of executive power.
Liberals rejoiced when Obama was re-elected. But until he does more to reverse the declines in workers' power and in the government's respect for civil liberties, he is not the total package.
Read the latest political news.
- Has Obama Kept His Open-Government Pledge?
- State of the Union Allows Presidents to Outline Agenda
- State of the Union Address Likely to Focus on Domestic Issues
- Obama Again Offers to Negotiate Big Deficit Deal
- Immigration Reform Plan is a Farce
- The GOP Crack-up and Obama's Unraveling of the Republican Coalition
- GOP: Rest in Peace?
- A Time to Build
- Obama's Challenge
- Obama's Debt-Ceiling Strategy Could Put The Squeeze on GOP
- Obama's Battle Hymn of the Republic
- Why I'm Singing the Inauguration Blues
- Obama's Inaugural Address Not Progressive Enough
- Taking Joe Biden Seriously
- Targeting Hillary Clinton
- Hillary Clinton Grilled, Punches Back
- Hillary Clinton's Dodgy Testimony
- Wake Up, Socially Liberal Fiscal Conservatives
- When Big Deficits Became Good
- No Labels, No Excuses
- Another Second Inauguration
- Obama 2.0: The Sequel
- Big Government 2.0
- Oh, Yesterday Went Suddenly
- Time to Grow Up, GOP
- Roe v. Wade at 40
- An Imperial President
- Obama's Flip-Flops on Money in Politics
- Control Politicians, Not Guns
- Obama Goes Big on Gun Control, But Can He Deliver?
- Appropriate Job for Big NRA Backer
- Female vs Male Senators
- Chuck Hagel: A Petty Decision by Obama
- Chuck Hagel and Defense
- U.S. Policy as Global Security Provider Built on Plymouth Rock
- Avoiding the Wars That Never End
- I Am Because You Are
- Warm Coats and Inaugural Memories
- War On Pot Has Gone Up in Smoke
- Second Amendment Vigilantes
- Obama Calls for Debt Ceiling Increase
- Don't Blame Me if Obama's Second Term Disappoints
- Debt Ceiling: Let's Pay Our Bills
- The Billionaires' Long Game
- GOP: Groping Old Party
- On to the Next Cliff
- Congress and the Fiscal Cliff: More of the Same
- The Dropped Ball
- Fiscal Cliff Deal Won't End War Between Democrats and Republicans
- Joe Biden Has the Last Laugh
- When Uncle Sam Pays Dividends
- Winning Ugly: Obama and the Fiscal Cliff
- Obama's 2013 priorities -- and Guns
- The Year That Was in Politics
- 2012: When Dreams Died
- Don't Tread on Six-Toed Cats
- The Crisis of the Middle Class and American Power
- What Price U.S. Citizenship?
- The Geopolitics of Immigration
- The Great New-Year Stampede
- Not So Merry Christmas For Congress and President
- John Boehner's 'Plan B' Gamble
- Republicans Would Rather Upgrade Afghan Infrastructure Than Our Own
- Who's Afraid of the Fiscal Cliff?
- The Kingdom of Fairness
Obama's Inaugural Address Not Progressive Enough | Politics
(c) 2013 Tribune Media Services, Inc