Race Card Season Again?
by Clarence Page
After years of mostly hedging any suggestion that racism has anything to do with President
"To a significant extent, the Republican base does have elements that are animated by racism," said Rep.
Asked by host
"Not all of them?" Gee, Congressman, care to name names?
Israel's comment was particularly notable because it came only a few days after an even more prominent Democrat, House Minority Leader
"I think race has something to do with the fact that they are not bringing up an immigration bill," she said at a news conference. "I've heard them say to the Irish, 'If it was you, it would be easy.' "
She didn't say who she heard talking to which "Irish," but she sounded like an old-school wheeler-dealer in the sort of ethnic-tribal politics that have produced big turnouts for generations of urban Democrats.
That's partly because she was responding to a question about Attorney General
Without specifically mentioning race, Holder heatedly suggested that the "unwarranted, ugly and divisive adversity" that he received from Republicans during a
"What attorney general has ever had to deal with that kind of treatment?" he said. "What president has ever had to deal with that kind of treatment?"
Holder didn't mention race because he didn't have to. As an African-American speaking to a group that conservatives love like they love the Ebola virus, his remarks sounded like a black-oriented version of what liberals would call a racially coded "dog whistle" if it had come from right-wing whites.
What's going on? Why, after years of accusing Republicans of unfairly accusing Democrats of playing the race card, do top Democrats seem suddenly to be throwing all caution to the winds. Why? Three theories come to mind:
Theory One: Anger.
A lot of it is pent-up among Democrats after a half-dozen years of playing nice to help their Big Guy in the
Theory Two: Fear.
As mid-term elections approach, what better way to rev up their liberal and heavily nonwhite base for the mid-terms than to highlight differences with conservatives over issues of racial and gender equality? A common theme connects congressional Democrats alleging racism and President Obama's promotions of pay equity and warnings about conservative rollbacks in the Voting Rights Act.
Theory Three: Shameless self-promotion.
Such was the case, Garrett offers, when the
Indeed, the same can be said of the return of race to center stage among top Democrats, generating familiar countercharges of "race baiting" and "playing the race card" from Republicans.
Sure, those of us who care about serious issues and nuanced politics should bristle at crude appeals to racial passions by either side. But as long as it turns out votes, the politics of rage are not going away soon, color-coded or not.