Senate Looks at Holds and Confirmation Delays
Alex M. Parker
A new rule aims to prevent secret holds on legislation
The Senate overwhelmingly approved a new rule which aims to forbid secret holds, the long-time Senate practice which allows a senator to anonymously delay a bill or presidential nomination. The new rule was part of a bipartisan compromise between Republican, and some Democratic, senators who defended the Senate's current procedure, and some Democratic senators who were pushing for more drastic reforms.
But despite the new rule, some parliamentary experts are skeptical that the Senate has truly put secret holds into the dustbin. The practice has survived several previous attempts to ban them, and so long as party leaders are willing to block bills on behalf of their caucus members, they may be impossible to completely eliminate.
Senatorial holds are powerful bargaining tools, due to the Senate's time-consuming process for moving forward with bills or nominations. In order to speed things up, the majority leader often asks for unanimous consent to bypass the usual procedure and move to an immediate vote. Any senator can halt such a move by objecting. Over the years, the Senate created rules for holds as a way for a senator to inform the majority leader ahead of time that he or she intends to object. That gives the leader time to either win the senator over, or drop the bill and move on to another matter. In the past, senators have been allowed to place a hold without their name becoming public. A 2007 reform was supposed to crack down on the secret holds, but senators found creative ways to game the rules.
Reformers hope that the rules passed last week will finally put an end to the practice, by requiring that any senator who places a hold is revealed within two days. Unlike in the past, the senator's name would be revealed, regardless of whether he or she drops the hold. But Senate experts wonder how much the new rule will change. "In theory, it could work," says Sarah Binder, a Brookings Institute scholar. "It comes down to expectations of changing people's behavior. This particular new rule doesn't have the jaws to make it happen."
Binder noted that party leaders may continue to block legislation on behalf of other senators, as they often have done in the past. It's also possible that senators will simply ignore or go around the rules, which Binder said has happened during the past Congress . Martin Gold, an attorney and former staffer for then-Republican Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist, agreed that ultimately it will come down to whether senators follow the spirit of the law. "I'm not sure it makes immense difference," Gold says.
Supporters of the bill acknowledge that a senator could still object on behalf of a secret colleague. But the senator who initially places the hold would still be accountable. "If you're objecting on behalf of someone, you'll have to be comfortable having your name on the record," says Jennifer Hoelzer, a spokeswoman for Democratic Senator Ron Wyden of Oregon, the sponsor of the new rule resolution.
Another rules change adopted by the Senate would prevent a senator from requiring that lengthy amendments be read aloud by Senate clerks. That tactic was rare, but was sometimes used by opponents of a bill to tie it up for hours, or even days. Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid and Minority Leader Mitch McConnell also reached a hand-shake agreement to restrain two controversial parliamentary tactics. Reid promised to rarely "fill the tree," which prevents the minority party from submitting amendments to a bill. In return, McConnell promised to cut down on filibusters for motions to proceed to a bill, the first part of considering a bill. The minority party would still have a chance to filibuster a bill when a motion is made for a vote.
Observers say that the most substantive reform to come from the bipartisan deal is to exempt about a third of the president's appointees from Senate confirmation. Two years into his presidency, Barack Obama still has yet to fill more than a hundred positions in his administration, due to the time-consuming process of getting so many nominees confirmed. The reform, which will require legislation instead of a rules change, has yet to be voted on in the Senate.
Read the latest political news.
- The Two-Party System is Making America Ungovernable
- Obama's Budget Falls Short of Deficit Panel Recommendations
- Republican Budgetary Woes
- Smoke, Mirrors and Other Deceptions
- Chicken Little and the Debt Ceiling
- Healthcare Reform Law Requires New IRS Army Of 1,054
- GOP Falling Into the Same Healthcare Trap That Snared Democrats
- Obama and Big Business the Unlikeliest of Neighbors
- How Business Can Do Business With Obama
- Mitt Romney Takes Aim at Obama During CPAC Speech
- Palin Leads GOP Presidential Hopeful Fundraising Race
- George H.W. Bush Has Earned the Presidential Medal of Freedom
- Liberals Mobilize to Save PBS and NPR Funding
- Senate Looks at Holds and Confirmation Delays
- Seeking the Real Ronald Reagan
- Told You So
- Impending Debate Over Spending Cuts Has Nothing to Do With Reviving Economy
- The Great Jobs Recession Goes On
- Pruning Farm Subsidies
- What Today's Leaders Can Learn From Ronald Reagan
- Reagan and Obama: Differently Similar
- Ronald Reagan: The 40th President at 100
- The Myth of JFK as Supply Side Tax Cutter
- Is Obama's Pro-Business Rhetoric for Real?
- Barack Obama's Progressive Problem
- Obama's Sputnik Analogy Doesn't Fly
- Obama Challenges America to Win the Future
- Why Congress Should Repeal and Replace the Healthcare Reform Law
- Healthcare Reform Law Repeal Would Be Inhumane
- 10 Ways the GOP Can Take Down Healthcare Reform
- Preexisting Conditions Common in United States
- Obama's Plan Would Cost Another $20 Billion
- Sensible Budget Must Include Investment in Our Future
- Freedom From Our Incessantly Growing Union
- Balance of Power
- The National Empathy Divide
- Obama and the Polls
- Obama Bounces Back
- The Loud Passing of the Old Order
- The Speech: Obama's State of the Union
- Obama Looks Good Halfway Through His Presidency
- Bipartisan Support for Making the Tax Code Simpler
- Obama's 'Freeze' Rehashes Failed 2010 Try
- The Spending Cuts Challenge
- Obama Should Challenge Country to Make a Clean Energy Automobile
- Obama's State of the Unions Less 'Intelligent' Than Bush's
- The Sorry State of Our Economic Union
- Looking Ahead and Back
- Obama Remembers JFK
- Reagan and Kennedy Are Role Models for Obama
- We Were Young For One, Brief Shining Moment
- Reagan Son Claims Dad Had Alzheimer's as President
- The Modern Military-Industrial Complex
- Why Sarah Palin Is Wrong About Michelle Obama's Weight Gain Fight
- After Repeal Vote, Healthcare Reform Fight Goes On
- GOP Attack on Health Care Shows Why Democrats Should Have Pushed Medicare for All
- Republicans Play Games with Health Care
- Giffords Shooting in Arizona Spurs Gun Law Debate
- Violent Rhetoric Can Lead to Tragedies Like Arizona Shooting
- Political Tone Had No Role in Arizona Shootings
- 10 States With the Largest Budget Shortfalls
- Contrasts in Black and Red
- The Bloomberg Syndrome
- The Enemies of Our Enemies are Our Friends
- Spiritual Death
- For (and Against) the Filibuster
- Who Needs Democracy?
- On Sargent Shriver
- Why are Republicans Doing This?
- Muslim 'Cosby' Show? Couldn't Hurt
- New Congress to Push Obama on Latin America
- Eisenhower's 'Military-Industrial Complex' and JFK's Inaugural
- Republicans Break Their Promises On Day One
- Speaker Boehner: Will He (Republican) Party Like It's 1995?
- Dysfunctional Duo's undoing
- The Tab Comes Due in 2011
- Incoming Republican Leadership Reeks of Corporate Control
- For the 112th Time: New Congress, Same Challenges
- Obama and Human Rights: Continuity and Change
- Despite Critics, Palin's Buzz Is Positive
- Moment of Silence Needs to Be Followed by More Than Just Lowered Voices
- Tests of a New Political Tone
- At Time of Healing, Sarah Palin Throws Gas on Flames
- The Liberal Empire Strikes Back
- The New Sophists
- Fishing for Democratic Corruption
- The Shameful Attack on Public Employees
- The Stealth Attack on American Education
- Obama Faces the Same Problems in 2011
- GOP's John Boehner Gets House Speaker's Gavel
- Good Teen Pals = Good Politics?
- Boehner, Pelosi, Haley, Ryan and Others to Watch in 2011
- New Era of Bipartisanship in 2011? No Chance
- Congress to Tackle Healthcare and Filibuster Rules
- Democrats Push for Filibuster Rule Change
- Republicans Charge Harry Reid Power Grab on Filibuster
- Lame Duck Session Was Successful For The President's Party
- Constitutionalists vs. 'Interpretationists'
- 2010 Midterm Elections Set Campaign Spending Records
- Biden Hints at Obama Reelection Themes
- Obama's Toughest Year Ahead?
- How Obama Is Failing at the Dramatic Side of the Presidency
- The Founding Fathers: Religion and God
- Ham-and-Egg Justice
- Obama's Hawaii Vacation Is Revealing
- Like Sarah Palin Early Feminists Were Pro-Life
- They're Back! The Return of the Death Panels
- Don't Reignite 'Death Panel' Insanity
- Sarah Palin: She Told Us So
- Why the Rich Are Getting Richer
- A Far From Happy New Year
- The American 21st Century
- Defense Is On The Table
- A Leaner and Meaner Defense
- The Political Power of Social Media
- The Good News About Gas
Available at Amazon.com:
Senate Looks at Holds and Confirmation Delays | Politics
(c) 2011 U.S. News & World Report