Tests of a New Political Tone
The country won't have to wait very long to find out whether President Obama's lecture on the tone of political discourse has borne fruit in the wake of the
The opening indications are not particularly hopeful.
Not satisfied with repeatedly referring to that law as "Obamacare" with derogation clearly implied, the House Republicans are calling the vehicle for eradicating it the "Repealing the Job-Killing Health Care Law Act."
Democratic suggestions that the "job-killing" reference be dropped have been flatly rejected by its sponsors. The clear objective is to push through the repeal legislation quickly as a fulfillment of the 2010
The proposed action confirms that the effort is theatrical rather than substantive, inasmuch as upon arrival in the
The apparent Republican strategy is to score this political point first and then have appropriate House committees draft new legislation embodying the reforms the party has in mind. It's in keeping with the "repeal and replace" battle cry of the successful 2010 midterm congressional campaign, but offering those fixes in the repeal bill would have put more substance into what is now the initial step of meat-axing "Obamacare."
There is always a chance the much sought-for civility mutually proclaimed in the wake of the
But the real test of any new civility will come when the Republicans offer the specific provisions they want in their own health-care replacement legislation. Retaining decorum may not be so easy in the House once the Republicans take aim at provisions in the new law for which there is a substantial constituency in the country.
The Democrats are already welcoming the opportunity to defend the protection of care for pre-existing medical conditions, the extension of dependent health care to age 26 and other features of particular interest to the elderly and the young. Efforts to cut or reduce the effects of such provisions are likely to imperil whatever civility exists on either side of the health-care debate.
The temptation to resort to misrepresentation in challenging the new law remains present and potentially effective. Prior to enactment, critics like
Later, when it came to light that a provision for such reasonable counseling was included in the statute, administration officials quickly removed it, contending there had not been sufficient public discussion of the proposal. But an obvious reason was fear of resurrecting the "death panel" myth.
A more substantive debate, rife with potential for heated and angry discourse, is likely to be over the federal mandate on the uninsured to buy health-care insurance. This question already is under judicial review in more than 20 states over its constitutionality. The matter ought to be dealt with without rancor, but it has the potential of disintegration into squabbles over patriotism, class warfare and other catalysts for name-calling and slander.
The Republican leadership's reply was that members could sit wherever they wanted. And so it goes.
Read the latest political news.
Available at Amazon.com:
- Eisenhower's 'Military-Industrial Complex' and JFK's Inaugural
- Republicans Break Their Promises On Day One
- Speaker Boehner: Will He (Republican) Party Like It's 1995?
- Dysfunctional Duo's undoing
- The Tab Comes Due in 2011
- Incoming Republican Leadership Reeks of Corporate Control
- For the 112th Time: New Congress, Same Challenges
- Obama and Human Rights: Continuity and Change
- Despite Critics, Palin's Buzz Is Positive
- Moment of Silence Needs to Be Followed by More Than Just Lowered Voices
- Tests of a New Political Tone
- At Time of Healing, Sarah Palin Throws Gas on Flames
- The Liberal Empire Strikes Back
- The New Sophists
- Fishing for Democratic Corruption
- The Shameful Attack on Public Employees
- The Stealth Attack on American Education
- Obama Faces the Same Problems in 2011
- GOP's John Boehner Gets House Speaker's Gavel
- Good Teen Pals = Good Politics?
- Boehner, Pelosi, Haley, Ryan and Others to Watch in 2011
- New Era of Bipartisanship in 2011? No Chance
- Congress to Tackle Healthcare and Filibuster Rules
- Democrats Push for Filibuster Rule Change
- Republicans Charge Harry Reid Power Grab on Filibuster
- Lame Duck Session Was Successful For The President's Party
- Constitutionalists vs. 'Interpretationists'
- 2010 Midterm Elections Set Campaign Spending Records
- Biden Hints at Obama Reelection Themes
- Obama's Toughest Year Ahead?
- How Obama Is Failing at the Dramatic Side of the Presidency
- The Founding Fathers: Religion and God
- Ham-and-Egg Justice
- Obama's Hawaii Vacation Is Revealing
- Like Sarah Palin Early Feminists Were Pro-Life
- They're Back! The Return of the Death Panels
- Don't Reignite 'Death Panel' Insanity
- Sarah Palin: She Told Us So
- Why the Rich Are Getting Richer
- A Far From Happy New Year
- The American 21st Century
- Defense Is On The Table
- A Leaner and Meaner Defense
- The Political Power of Social Media
- The Good News About Gas
- Post-Census Party-Pooping
- The Would-be GOP Kings
- Generation Next
- Every Man a King
- Believe in Violence and Be Saved
- Inside the Tea Party Revolution
- John Boehner, Sarah Palin and When Crying Is OK in Politics
- Obama and Clinton Share Personality Traits
- Grand Compromise Brings More Spending
- Barack Obama: The New Comeback Kid
- Swimming in Blessings; Drowning in Complaints
- Time for the 2010 Freeby Awards
- A Reliable Prediction
- The Year Washington Became 'Business-Friendly'
- South American Diary
- Obama's Pending Assignment: Reconnecting With Hispanics and Latin America
- Our Government has Become Greedy
- When Will Obama Go 'Gangster'
- Transcending Progressive Discord
- John Boehner's Curious Tears
- A Tractable and Pragmatic President
- The President's Tax Deal Is Just More Trickle-Down Economics
- President Obama: A Decent Deal, a Weak Sales Job
- Questions for Democrats
- The American Jobs Emergency Requires Action
- Why Not Soak the Rich?
- President Obama Takes on the Liberal Democrats
- President Obama's Surrender
- Reigniting the Spirit of 2008
- Learning the Constitution Is Essential for Americans
- Obama-Clinton's Tag Team Show
- Behind Bill Clinton's Smile
- Obama Tax Deal Debate Is a Classic Beltway Christmas Story
- Voters Say Obama Has No Clear Narrative
- When Words Fail
- 10 Senate Democrats Targeted for Defeat in 2012
- Senators Amass Campaign War Chests Ahead of 2012
- Redefining the Global Warming Debate
- The Need to Protect Our Aging Workforce
- First They Came for My Twinkie ...
- More Nixon Wisdom
- Politics Without Labels? What a Silly Concept
- No Backslide for House Ethics
- Obamacare in Critical Condition
- The Death of Health Care Reform
- Sarah Palin's Economy
- In a Giving Mood But Only Toward Rich
- Congress Must Help Struggling Families Not Millionaires
Tests of a New Political Tone | Politics
(c) 2011 Tribune Media Services, Inc.